Results of the Experiment based on EON2002 models
Successful import after
manually removing the XML-namespace “a:”
KAON
Failed to import classes
as rdf:description with rdf:type Class
WebODE
We did not try to
convert the text / Oil files
Terminae
Using RDFS import.
Ignored by SemTalk RDFS
Import even if the SemTalk engine could represent them:
·OverridingProperty
·Cardinalities
·Allowed Values /
Defaultvalues
·All Data types
·Inverse properties are
mapped as properties
Protégé
We did not try to
convert the Smalltalk files
OpenKnoME
·Since SemTalk has only an F-Logik export and not an F-Logik
import function, the flo file could not be imported.
·Using DAML import classes, instances and properties could be
imported. Cardinalities are ignored.
OntoEdit
After fixing some
SemTalk DAML import issues, a subset of the model could be imported. The OildEd model differs
significantly from the other models because it makes frequent use of DAML features which are
not supported by SemTalk for DAML: intersectionOf, unionOf etc.
On the other hand, this model is close to OWL. We tried to
rename some XML elements to OWL, but finally failed
to import it mainly because of the combination of “cons”-ed Lists and operators.
OilEd
We did not try to
convert the Lisp files
Loom